Hathor legacy is a cultural criticism site with the tagline “in search of good female characters.” They recently revamped things by consolidating their multiple feeds into a single one (they also have a LJ feed), so this seemed like a good time to link. The design of the core site doesn’t excite me, the text is a little big and you need to read more to get the details on any post. However, that’s not an issue with the feeds, so I don’t really care.
My favorite discussion has been one by guest author Audra on Laura Roslin, the female President in Battlestar Gallactica. The write-up does a good job of both addressing her strengths and acknowledging that she does make a fair number of iffy decisions. The discussion went off topic some, but added more analysis and kept the things interesting well after the initial post.
A second post I enjoyed was one I disagreed with put up by Kris Ligman. She thought Portal did more to advance female protagonists than Mirror’s Edge because the latter’s marketing was really driven by its main character. Loving both games, I disagreed, as did other commenters, but while the discussion was a bit harsh on Kris I think she handled herself well and updated her views as new info came to light. Potential for good discussion really is key in my view to a good criticism site. Another fun series by the same author is a salutary set of pieces on the women of Metal Gear Solid.
The site was started by Jennifer Kesler who both gets a nice mix of writers and wades into comments as a moderator when appropriate, which is key to getting the commenting community that I enjoy.
I took a look at some of the posts, and I agree, it does seem pretty interesting. Thanks for pointing it up, Greg.
Posted by: Moti | May 21, 2009 at 04:09 PM
Hey, thanks so much for the mention! :)
Posted by: Jennifer Kesler | May 22, 2009 at 12:09 AM
Jennifer: You're quite welcome. Thanks for being a fun place to visit and chat.
Moti: Glad you like it. I have hoped the blog roll updates would be useful to someone.
Posted by: Greg Sanders | May 22, 2009 at 12:37 AM